3.6M
Downloads
329
Episodes
The one true A SONG OF ICE AND FIRE Re-Read Podcast by PoorQuentyn and ManuclearBomb
Episodes
Monday Apr 09, 2018
Monday Apr 09, 2018
Hello and welcome back to the NotACast, the one true chapter-by-chapter podcast going through A Song of Ice and Fire one chapter a week!
Today, Emmett and Jeff are pleased to present you with "Catelyn Might Have Done Something Wrong Right There: An Analysis of AGOT, Jon II": a three-act chapter which has Jon leaving Winterfell forever (but probably not)
This week, we talk:
- Answers to some of your burning questions
- Jon's illusions being dashed in his farewells to Winterfell
- Jon's outsider role as a defining force in the entirety of his arc
- The excellent three-act structure of the chapter
- Subtle warging hints!
- "Stick 'em with the pointy end" and its importance for Arya
- Our Independence Day/ASOIAF mashup
- And finally and not at all controversially, we tackle the question of "Is Catelyn Stark evil or a bitch or abusive to Jon Snow?"
This is a meaty episode.
Next Week: Daenerys Targaryen gets married in barbarian splendor!
Our patreon: https://www.patreon.com/NotACastASOIAF
Our twitter: https://twitter.com/NotACastASOIAF
Emmett's tumblr: http://poorquentyn.tumblr.com/
Emmett's twitter: https://twitter.com/PoorQuentyn
Jeff's twitter: https://twitter.com/BryndenBFish
Comments (7)
To leave or reply to comments, please download free Podbean or
Going back through this chapter always reminds me of my belief that Cat is the worst and who she emerges as through Stoneheart is her true self. I know so many love her and that's great. I just can't, I can't forgive, like or get aboard the Cat train. Anyhoo, great episode as always. Yall are the best.
Friday Apr 09, 2021
I'm not so sure that "constitutional democracies aren't good because there's still bad people around to potentially abuse that system" is a very good argument against it.
Friday Oct 05, 2018
Jon’s description is very very similar to what Bran describes when he first sees BR. Coincidence? I think not....
Tuesday Oct 02, 2018
When Jon enters Bran’s room, what does Jon’s description of Bran remind you of?
Tuesday Oct 02, 2018
Properly functioning constitutional democracies don’t go to war against other properly functioning constitutional democracies. That’s one of the perks of elected democratic governments, and one of the scary things about strong man dictatorships that are currently acting to consolidate power all over the world.
Monday Apr 09, 2018
you guys are not stupid or ugly. Kirt Russell is the correct Wyatt and Val Kilmer is the only Doc Holiday. You do a pretty go job analyzing ASOIAF too.
Monday Apr 09, 2018
Time to start the best not a cast on the net!
Monday Apr 09, 2018
To leave or reply to comments,
please download free Podbean App.